I’ve Reached my Cynical Melting Point (ALS Ice Bucket Challenge)

The way this spread across the social media (and physical space) is amazing. It spreads like a benevolent fungus, and but the transmission method is purely through relationships, boosted through social media.

(Interestingly, this same challenge could have been a more unknown trend twenty years ago, even with the same amount of spread among the population, since you wouldn’t be detecting the ambient splashes of your neighbors and friends as easily…)

It’s success has a lot to do with its positive narrative (donation to a worthy cause) and its inherent spectacle. Watching someone do this is automatic drama: what will happen next? How will they react? On top of this, it’s easy to do… an ice-cube tray and an ice-cream bucket was all I used.

People are against it, which is a natural response whenever something like this reaches a critical mass consciousness. I’m pretty cynical, but I have to say there’s not a lot of weak points in this sort of event. Even if people are doing it for the ‘wrong reasons’, such as gaining attention or following a trend, or if there are more deadly or widespread diseases to fight (thereby making ALS the ‘wrong disease’) it doesn’t take away that millions have been raised, and are still being raised, through this philanthropy virus that you catch from your friends.

The act of pouring ice-cold water over your head is an intense experience. Knowing that you’re doing it as part of a cultural event makes it almost like a rite of passage. (Or less charitably, a hazing ritual.) You will not anticipate exactly how cold that water is until you do it, and having done it, you will have passed through a liminal state, not unlike the freezing point of water. Maybe your resolve will harden, or your cynicism will melt, depending on which way you want to take the metaphor.

I’ve been seeing a lot of people online who seem to define themselves through negatives, through what they hate or oppose. There is something inherently optimistic about defining yourself as being part of something, especially something that isn’t complicated. And having participated in something thousands or even millions of others have done makes me feel like I’m truly participating in humanity, both locally and long-range. When I see friends, celebrities, and strangers participate, I feel like we’re all in the same club, without a lot of the baggage that these memberships often claim.


2 thoughts on “I’ve Reached my Cynical Melting Point (ALS Ice Bucket Challenge)

  1. Hear, hear. I think all the objections were pretty nakedly people accustomed to hating things that have become too popular reaching for excuses. I get that seeing the same joke over and over can become tiresome, but none of the objections held any water (no pun intended).

    People are doing it for the wrong reasons? Can’t see why that matters at all. The awareness and (sometimes) money still happens even if the motives aren’t pure.

    Other charities are more deserving? For most people, charity isn’t a zero sum game where they carefully budget their donation sums for the year, meaning $10 or a $100 here takes it away from somewhere else. This wasn’t taking money from heart disease. It was taking money from people’s bar tabs or iTunes accounts. It created charitable donations where none would have otherwise existed.

    My favourite? The water-wasting excuse. If these people stayed in the shower for an extra minute or flushed a kleenex down the drain the day they were whining about the environment, they wasted more money than a bucket of water.

    This was a good thing. Just because lame people did it to doesn’t change that.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s